Author: djensen
Last saved by: Money4Davey
Company: ITT/ESI

Peer Review Questionnaire

Question | Reviewer’s Comment
Thesis Statement
Can I find it? |
Does the thesis state the main idea and some of the reasoning behind that idea? |
Is all of the textual evidence clearly related to the thesis? |
Coherence and Clarity
Do any ideas seem vague? |
Is the purpose of the essay clear? |
Content
Is there a structure to the paper? |
Can I determine the logic behind it? |
What are the most interesting/convincing sections of the paper? |
Style
Is the style appropriate for the intended audience? |
Is the research thoroughly documented |
Grammar and Mechanics
Grammar |
Punctuation |
Spelling |
Recommended Changes
Please recommend three specific changes in the writing.